The Civil War
Brother Against Brother
After Union soldier John McLaughlin took his Confederate brother prisoner, it took nearly 40 years before they met again.
After Union soldier John McLaughlin took his Confederate brother prisoner, it took nearly 40 years before they met again.

After John McLaughlin in Union army captured his brother Henry, Confederacy, in 1863 in Mississippi, many believed the brothers never saw each other again. But then something happened while John was hunting in Kansas, which made him decide to write apology to Henry for having called him a traitor, and requested they travel from Kansas and Alabama to a cousin’s farm in Indiana. John kept writing to Henry for years until finally, in their 70s around 1900, they agreed to meet.
As John McLaughlin explained to his Indiana cousin, Red Reed (from whom I acquired all photos and story in this frame), when he sent him the hunting photo, he began to think about the symbolic connection of the deers which had doomed them when they had locked horns, like he and Henry’s mental and emotional horns are locked over Civil War experience, now destroying any future to renew the brotherhood they once had as youth!
After years of John writing Henry many apologetic letters, they finally set up their healing reunion on cousin Red Reed’s Marion, Indiana, farm as chronicled in the photo of John (left) and Henry (right), who are smiling in joy of unlocked horns of bitterness leading to their living out lives of brotherly love! Mr. Reed told me the McLaughlin family had remained fractured over the war; John and Henry remained reunited through periodic meetings until one died.
In these framed pieces, Jim tells the story of each object and, importantly, preserves his original research and documentation. In many instances, the story concludes on the back of the frame. In cases where the similarity of content may cause confusion for viewers, the beginning of the story is highlighted.