The Civil War
The Blueberry Pie
Union solider Josephus Hollingsworth was no match for “the girls” of Paris, Kentucky.
Union solider Josephus Hollingsworth was no match for “the girls” of Paris, Kentucky.

In 1975, I received a call. Loud voice announced, “Hollingsworth here! I have research project worth your expertise. Want you to come to St. Marys, and after studying items I’ve inherited relating to Civil War ancestor Josephus Hollingsworth, which includes original photo and letters, paying you what it’s worth to research and write up his complete story! Be here tomorrow at noon. Don’t be late!”
This man was so offensively abrasive, I had no interest in meeting him, let alone working on his project; but then before hanging up he had added “From family stories all we know is he was a General and was killed in the battle of Paris, Kentucky.” Quick home research showed he was not a General, and there was no battle in Paris, Kentucky. This misinformation intrigued me enough, I decided to go to meet Mr. Hollingsworth.
Morning research before our meeting revealed Josephus Hollingsworth was in Company K, 99th O.V.I, having never rose beyond rank of sergeant and though no battle there, had died in 1862 at Paris, Kentucky. Being just as arrogant in person as he had been on phone, showed me Josephus’ tintype photo in officer’s uniform and his letters home (which obviously owner had never read, by negative data they exposed!) Letters exposed ancestor as egotistical as their owner, admits he had upon entering service as private, chosen at photo studio an officer’s uniform, even sporting a false beard to appear more distinguished. Letters further listed acts of heroism which earned him ever higher ranking positions up to Company Commander.
My research showed all were lies fed to family, to be fed to friend who was newspaper writer; final letter gave explanation for all this deceit in Josephus’ declaration to friend, “Most powerful stepping stones to a political career are an impressive military background!”
The photo was a fake! The letters revealed an arrogant, corrupt man who was not above any pretense to paint a positive picture of himself as preparation for a post-war political career! But there was one fact which had been true. Josephus Hollingsworth had died at Paris, Kentucky! I decided I had to go to Paris, Kentucky for the final truth of the story.
After couple hours discovering nothing related to the Josephus Hollingsworth story in a small local historical museum in Paris, Kentucky, I was approached by elderly museum worker who asked me what I was researching. When I told him, he wrote an address, saying slyly, “Here’s where you might find what you’re looking for.” Address lead to elderly local historian, who responded to my story with cryptic remark “Probably victim of the girls.”
“The girls” turned out to be two eccentric, old maid sisters who had lost number of relatives fighting for the Confederacy in Civil War. This loss was cause of their vengeful plan, using small roadside eatery where they were known for their wonderous blueberry pies! They made special pies for any Union soldier (Yankees now occupying town) who happened to stop to eat. How tempting those pies to soldiers living on troop food! The girls’ pies were filled with berries for Union troops, with an unhealthy, deadly dose of rat poison! Most one-piece victims died well out of town, but couple soldiers who were weakest died on the street after eating more than one piece of pie. When determined they had been poisoned, those who suspected the sisters had taken them to a place of hiding.
After going to site of the sisters’ long-gone eatery, I drove home wondering if “the girls'” story was related to the fate of Josephus Hollingsworth (figuring an ass like him would have gobbled down an entire pie and died on the spot!) A month later, doing unrelated research in History Western Ohio and Auglaize County, I discovered the following in Civil War records: Josephus Hollingsworth, private, Company K, 99th O.V.I. DIED AT PARIS, KENTUCKY, POISONED BY EATING PIE IN A RESTAURANT. I called the relative of “the girls,” from whom I received the original tintype photo of them, and shared what I had found. I jokingly added, “Perhaps Paris should erect life-sized bronze statue of the sisters, stepping forward with a tray of blueberry pies, because truth is they had probably killed more Yankee soldiers than anyone else in the Confederacy!”
In these framed pieces, Jim tells the story of each object and, importantly, preserves his original research and documentation. In many instances, the story concludes on the back of the frame. In cases where the similarity of content may cause confusion for viewers, the beginning of the story is highlighted.